12 Comments
User's avatar
David Shaw's avatar

A carefully crafted dance in the shadows between fact and supposition. Well done!

Expand full comment
Diane Burley's avatar

Thank you so much for your generous and descriptive words! And it was a dance of do I know or do I believe. So happy you enjoyed it.

Expand full comment
Julie Whitney's avatar

This is fascinating, Diane! You found so much information about William’s life in music. Very impressive research. Thank you for adding so much to my knowledge about him!

Expand full comment
Diane Burley's avatar

Julie, I am so glad you liked it. I couldn't have done this without your help! Without that obituary I was spinning in circles, thank you so much!

Expand full comment
Lisa Maguire's avatar

Wonderful piece. His military experience and his home on the border immediately made me think of Fenians… I wonder if there is even more to his past?

Expand full comment
Diane Burley's avatar

Oh lisa, I wondered that too. Was he “removed” because he was involved? I don’t see any evidence of that. I did wonder if that was why he was “removed,” but I couldn’t back up the supposition with anything.

Are you an expert in that area? Know of any databases I can crawl through?

Expand full comment
Lisa Maguire's avatar

I wouldn’t consider myself an expert, but I can see what I can find.

Expand full comment
Diane Burley's avatar

I did check where the British army was stationed — and it was Halifax and Montreal. Montreal is only a two hour drive to Potsdam (no idea how long by horseback). After William died, i found references that her youngest stayed with sisters in law. She had one brother. So that suggests he had at least one sister — natural or adopted. Would she have been a fenian too?

Expand full comment
Lisa Maguire's avatar

I looked a bit in Canadian sources and I didn't find anything useful. The British army stationed in Mtl would not have been part of the force to stop the Fenians at the border. But Potsdam is kind of a random place for him to end up. He must have had Fenian sympathies and part of that network of people who were living there.

Expand full comment
Diane Burley's avatar

I wonder how i might find out more. Was the US sympathetic to the fenians? Woule a Canadian with fenian sympathies be welcomed in the US? (Border laws didn’t become a thing until mid 1890s.)

Expand full comment
Lisa Maguire's avatar

Not sure anyone would necessarily know his sympathies since the Fenians were a secret society. Which is of course what makes this research so hard!!!

Expand full comment
Jill Swenson's avatar

Wow! You found out quite a bit about Mr. Barrry. Fascinating history.

Expand full comment